Next, the team moved on to the crime scene itself. Marty Annell, the maintenance man at the apartment complex where Anita lived, died by suicide a year after the murder. All rights reserved. It just totally pulled the rug out from beneath him, she said. In 2015, El Dorado County investigators again revived the case. Three boys, 1 girl, and 4 dogs. Part two airs on Oxygen Saturday at 7 p.m. CT. Carmen Asham, Det. See clips, previews, and more here on TNT's official YouTube channel.Connect with TNT Online:Visit the TNT WEBSITE: http://bit.ly/TNTSiteLike TNT on FACEBOOK: http://bit.ly/TNTFaceBookFollow TNT on TWITTER: http://bit.ly/TNTTwitter One of the shows investigators, Det. Now due to multi-state collaboration by numerous agencies her killer will finally be held accountable.. These investigations are credited with bringing about 37 arrests and 18 convictions. Was this true? Cold Justice is a real crime investigation series that first aired on TNT and is now available on Oxygen. Hours after Natasha Atchley left a party in Texas, her mother found her dead in her towed car. At this time, Scott is still being held at the Chester County Detention Center awaiting trial. This is a 25 year old cold case. When investigators confronted her with Mays claims about her drunken confession, she stopped the interview: I dont want to talk anymore, she said. She had seemed more concerned about a missing iPod than her slain friend, according to detectives who worked the case in 2007, and. Another suspect was Greg Weller, who was a potential witness for Mark Carter in court documents prior to the plea agreement Carter reached with prosecutors on the rape charge against him. On September 1st, the "Cold Justice" team traveled to Bailey County to investigate the 2006 unsolved homicide of 25-year-old Jonathan "Wongo" Kindle. Your IP: Kelly and Steve head into Louisiana to work with the Concordia Parish Sheriffs Office and investigate the 2016 homicide of a 26-year-old whose body was found on the banks of the bayou. The 1988 death of 49 year old Isabel Cordle in Bellevue, Ohio, is investigated. A question has floated for years about whether he felt guilty about Anita's death. On June 21, 2020, Gene Rogers, 61,and his mother, Billie Rogers,78, were found shot to death in their mobile home in Chester County, South Carolina. When the police arrived, Isabel's husband and three of her children were upstairs, scared and confused. Cold Justice is an investigative true crime series originally broadcast on TNT and currently on Oxygen. Carmen Asham, Det. Our daughters being charged for something she didnt do, he told Siegler. Kelly Siegler and her team of legal experts may be able to add another success story to their resume. Oxygen Insider is your all-access pass to never-before-seen content, free digital evidence kits, and much more. When detectives interviewed Schmaltz he said he never asked Anita out because he never got that courage.. They head to Wyoming to work with Carbon County Law Enforcement to look into the mysterious deaths of two women years apart, but connected by the same circle of friends. Kelly Siegler and Team Determined to Find Justice for Anita Knutsons Family, Cold Justice Team Reexamines Anita Knutson's Crime Scene, Kelly Siegler and Detective Carmen Asham Talk Small-Town Floods, Who fatally stabbed 18-year-old North Dakota college student. motel room in 1997. Was it a random act of violence, or did her strained marriage factor in to her murder? Will they be able to finally give answers to all the families involved? The Cold Justice team had worked on the case with local law enforcement several months earlier. Witnesses saw her having breakfast with an unknown male at the hotel restaurant. Cold Justice (2013- ) Episode List Season: OR Year: Season 5 S5, Ep1 4 Aug. 2018 Small Town Secrets 8.4 (38) Rate The case of 33-year-old married mother-of-two, Barbara Mendez, who was savagely beaten to death at her place of work in Oneida County, Wisconsin in 1982. Kelly and Johnny investigate one of their oldest cases ever -- the brutal 1984 murder of an elderly storeowner known for having a wife with a violent temper. Investigators are immediately suspicious because of the location of the gun shot to the back of Ben's head. In 1999, a dog brought a human skull into its yard. Sometime before 6:00 AM, someone sneaked up on her while she slept and hit her on the head with a hatchet four times, killing her. Cold Cases Crime News is your destination for true crime stories from around the world, breaking crime news, and information about Oxygen's original true crime shows and documentaries. Your First Look at the New Season of Cold Justice, Natasha Atchleys Brother Speaks with Cold Justice Team, Steve Spingola Tells the Story of the Ding-Dong Ditcher, returns to Oxygen on Saturday, September 3, veteran prosecutor. Suspect Terrance Staley plead guilty to fraud for stealing $600 from her credit card but claimed to not have anything to do with her murder. A preliminary hearing is scheduled for September 8, a deputy district clerk confirmed. Siegler an aggressive prosecutor prosecutor dubbed the "giant killer" secured death sentences in 19 of the 20 times she pursued capital punishment. She suffered 41 knife wounds, mainly to her face, neck, and hands. She was a recently widowed pensioner, and had a large family of 9 siblings, and one son. Please include what you were doing when this page came up and the Cloudflare Ray ID found at the bottom of this page. They determined theyhad sufficient circumstantial evidence suggesting that Nichole killed Anita to present to the prosecutor. They also said Anita hated going home because of the tense atmosphere. But when detectives dug deeper into his motives, Annells sister said that her brother was despondent over discovering that his longtime girlfriend was cheating on him. Sign up forOxygen Insiderfor all the best true crime content. You May Also Like. In TNT's "Cold Justice, " Kelly Siegler, a former Texas prosecutor for 21 years who has successfully tried 68 murder cases, and Yolanda McClary, a former crime scene investigator who worked. Could a scandalous town rumor have led to her death? Mikali Talbott, and Chief John Klug of the Minot Police Department, the team began with four suspects. The exchanges painted a pretty clear picture of escalating tension between the two young women, said Siegler, although i. n the initial 2007 investigation, Nichole downplayed the divide between her and Anita. Carmen Asham, Det. After reviewing all of the witness statements and evidence, investigators officially eliminated Annell and Vann as suspects. Inconsistencies, they thought, would be easier to spot this way. This is the second time TNT and Cold Justice had been sued by a subject of one of their shows in just over a year. Anita Knutson case to be featured on the Cold Justice 100th episode, Continuing Coverage of Anita Knutson Cold Case. By subscribing, I agree to the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. Published: Oct. 7, 2022 at 3:04 PM PDT MINOT, (KMOT) - The case of the 2007 killing of Minot college student Anita Knutson has drawn national attention of late, including a special two-part. Deadline is a part of Penske Media Corporation. Investigators concluded that Annell was looking less and less like a suspect. They'll need to pit them against each other to crack the case and finally bring justice to his family. Photo: Cold Justice is an unscripted true crime series originally broadcast on TNT and currently on Oxygen.The series, produced by Dick Wolf, follows former prosecutor Kelly Siegler and a team of investigators as they re-open unsolved murder cases with the consent of local law enforcement.As of January 2015, the team has helped local agencies secure 21 arrests, 11 criminal indictments, four . Another witness, however, told investigators that she suspected Tyler Schmaltz. Hosts of TNT's Cold Justice visited Gallatin in January to examine the unresolved murder case of Lydia Naomi Gutierrez, whose 8-year-old son found her suffocated and stabbed to death in August . During their initial investigation, police obtained a DNA sample through a sexual assault kit. From Executive Producer Dick Wolf, this real-life crime series follows former prosecutor Kelly Siegler and former CSI Yolanda McClary. Her body was discovered by her father, who checked on her after she failed to respond to his messages. Your IP: A neighbor discovered his body three days later, according to a, On June 29, 2022,the Texas County Sheriff's department. Where they go varies, but what theyre after stays constant: Getting justice. By recreating the scene, investigators saw that his claim actually made sense. A volunteer fireman shot to death in Missouri. He responded to queries about his whereabouts at the time of Anitas murder, and admitted he was aware that people had mentioned him as a possible killer and dealt with that the best he could. On June 4, 2007, Anitas mother grew concerned when her daughter didnt respond to calls, so. Kelly & Steve Spingola partner once again to work with the Potter County Sheriffs Department in Texas in investigating the brutal murder of a doting mother of four on Feb 25, 1994, Jackie Hogue. Debuting in September 2013, Cold Justice follows former Texas prosecutor Siegler and ex-crime scene investigator McClary as they work with local police to reopen and solve unresolved cases. He came across as a bit socially awkward, said Spingola. When she didnt answer her door, he went to her bedroom window. Get an all-access pass to never-before-seen content, free digital evidence kits, and much more! Dawn Glanz was a beloved and deeply respected Art History Professor at Bowling Green State University. But when detectives dug deeper into his motives, Annells sister said that her brother was despondent over discovering that his longtime girlfriend was cheating on him. Three Generations Gone: With Kelly Siegler, Tonya Rider, Grant Sperry, Kathryn Pinneri. Your First Look at the Newest Cases. On Monday, June 4, Marty Annell, the complexs maintenance man, observed that the screen was damaged and removed it. Thomas account for her whereabouts at the time of the murder have been inconsistent, according to Minot PD, which has increased suspicions. On February 13, 1973, the Rio Arriba County grand jury returned an indictment against defendant David G. Vigil, charging him with murder in violation of 40A-2-1, N.M.S.A., 1953 (2d Repl. And theyre good at it. Kelly and Abbey search for new clues in the fatal shooting of a mother of six that was initially considered a suicide. Cold Justice digs into murder cases that have lingered for years without answers. The final season three episode aired Sept. 18, 2015. Investigators hit a brick wall when DNA test results came back inconclusive, just as they had 15 years earlier. One suspect was Mark Carter (Cordle's Neighbor), who assaulted Isabel Cordle's son. Or was she trying to appear that way? He confirmed that the reports were just rumors. Samantha is the only suspect for the team. When "Cold Justice" returns to Oxygen on Saturday, September 3, veteran prosecutor Kelly Siegler and her seasoned fellow investigators are back to digging deep into unsolved homicides that have hung in limbo for years and even decades. Cold Justice: popular and now cancelled. They confirmed that Anita and Thomas had a contentious relationship. Jesse Hogue, 73, was arrested on March 21, 2019 in Pueblo County Colorado for the 1994 murder of his ex-wife, Jackie Hogue. Investigators next interviewed high school friends of Anita and Thomas to better understand their relationship and the degree of bad blood between them. Kittie's loss sent shockwaves of anguish through a family for decades. Vol. Annell had claimed that hed removed the damaged screen the day the crime was discovered to repair it but didnt see her dead inside the room. The plan was for Spingola and Asham to question Nichole, while Siegler and Talbott talked with her parents at the same time. It also is available online. Despite the severe congenital malformations in his body, as of 2023 the 'Man of Somiedo' remains unidentified. Kelly and Steve investigate the 2016 homicide of a hard-working mother who was strangled to death and dumped in a ditch. Experts explain it all to Oxygen.com. Season: OR Year: Season 2 S2, Ep1 17 Jan. 2014 Gone 9.3 (64) Rate The unsolved murder of Dawn Glanz may be closer to being cracked after the true crime TV show "Cold Justice" investigated the Bowling Green case. El Dorado County investigators worked with the Spokane Police Department on this case. The hit Oxygen series Cold Justice is set to return for Season 6 on July 10, and Kelly Siegler and her team of investigators are taking on a new slate of intense cold cases.. Rice was at work at the Minot Air Force Base at the time of her arrest. Messages between Anita and Nichole told a different story. Scuba Certification; Private Scuba Lessons; Scuba Refresher for Certified Divers; Try Scuba Diving; Enriched Air Diver (Nitrox) Kicking off on Saturday, September 3, six new episodes will arrive on a weekly basis with the landmark 100th episode airing across two parts on October 1 and October 8. The investigation uncovers family drama, rumors of doomsday prepping and a daughter waiting for her mother to return. In March 2022, the Minot Police arrested 34-year-old Nichole Rice for the murder. One of the longest-running, unscripted, true-crime series, Cold Justice is a crime show about unsolved cases. 'Cold Justice' Investigates, Ive seen a lot of crime scenes in my day, and this was clearly staged, said Spingola, adding that the killer must have entered through the front door. In a new episode of "Cold Justice," Kelly Siegler and her team of investigators travel to Texas to look into the murder of Natasha Atchley. CONCORDIA PARISH Sheriff's Office Captain Philip Webber (center) is shown with Steve Spingola and Kelly Siegler from the Oxygen Channel's show - "Cold Justice.". John Walsh interviews the investigative team for their behind-the-scenes insights. So, they focused their efforts on Nichole. Mar 1, 2019. Thats what Siegler and her rotating roster of investigators . ', 'Newsreaders' & More", "Friday Cable Ratings: 'Alaskan Bush People' Tops Night + 'Gold Rush', 'Jack & Triumph Show', NBA Basketball & More", "Friday Cable Ratings: 'Gold Rush' Wins Night, 'Bring It! On October 22, 2019, Ashley, then 42, was arrested and charged with first-degree murder. In part two of their investigation, the Cold Justice team continues to investigate three mysterious deaths in Wyoming. But her statements about where she was around the time of the murder kept wavering and the inconsistencies raised red flags. Home. Other evidence suggested that the killer never entered or exited through the bedroom window. After determining that it was highly unlikely that Ben shot himself in the back of the head, the team focuses on building a case against Samantha. Vann died from an asthma attack, an event unrelated to the case. Since our DNA was a bust, its clear witnesses will be the key to solving this murder, said Spingola. Suspects are Ed Nice, Laurie Lynn Soule, and Ken (Kimberly) Soule. Mike allegedly told another individual that he killed Anita, said Spingola. This is one of the oldest cold case murders in the country to be solved through a sexual assault DNA review run through CODIS, the FBIs combined DNA Index System. Gary was allegedly verbally and physically abusive towards his mother. The prosecuting attorney decides to take the case against Samantha to a grand jury, and she was arrested. Afterward, he'd taunt victims with horrific phone calls and threats. Kelly and Steve head to Harney County, Oregon to help solve the October 1993 murder of a young man allegedly shot and buried by a group of dangerous criminals. Create your free profile and get access to exclusive content. Oxygen is channel 30 on Midco cable in Minot. The patrons of the bar could hold the key to identifying her killer and getting her family justice. Exclusive updates on past cases and questions to Kelly and Yolanda were featured. In late-July 2017, Angelo E. Ruth pleaded guilty to the second-degree murder of Mattie Henry and was sentenced to 11 years in prison. Recommended by Zergnet MINOT, (KMOT) The case of the 2007 killing of Minot college student Anita Knutson has drawn national attention of late, including a special two-part investigation on the show Cold Justice.. 865. Key suspect was Anthony 'Tony' Ford. Did the killer enter and exit through the window of the bedroom where Anita was found dead in June 2007? Years later her body was discovered in a pine forest nearby. Sign up for Oxygen Insider for all the best true crime content. She had seemed more concerned about a missing iPod than her slain friend, according to detectives who worked the case in 2007, andSiegler and Spingola learned that the relationship between the roommates had soured to the point of being volatile. Her husband was working overseas in Japan, and it was rumored that she was having an affair. Although separated, she continued to take him to work every morning. The fact that Tyler Schmaltz was one of the first people on the scene in 2007 struck police as strange, according to Spingola. When she didnt answer her door, he went to her bedroom window. TNT had no response to the lawsuit today when contacted by Deadline. On August 18, 1997, she vanished. The production, taken as a whole, leaves the unmistakable impression with theaudience that the plaintiff is a killer and, specifically, that he was the perpetrator in the murder of Alma Noffsinger, without ever mentioning that the State of Ohio determined not to pursue the matter with the evidence it had in 1981, which was more than the evidence presented in the production, said the more recent filing by attorneys Michael Rumer, Victoria Maisch Rumer, Zachary Maisch and Andrea M. Brown of Lima, Ohio firm Rumer & Maisch Co. LLC. Unscripted, true-crime series, Cold Justice digs into murder cases that have lingered for years without.... Team continues to investigate three mysterious deaths in Wyoming a bit socially,! A brick wall when DNA test results came back inconclusive, just as they had 15 years earlier told. Dumped in a pine forest nearby in the fatal shooting of a mother of that. Her family Justice scandalous town rumor have led to her death got that courage where Anita lived died! Around the time of the location of the longest-running, unscripted, true-crime series, Cold Justice is an true. Are credited with bringing about 37 arrests and 18 convictions Steve investigate the 2016 homicide of a mother..., is investigated each other to crack the case and finally bring Justice to his family from! Scene in 2007 struck police as strange, according to Spingola Privacy.! A daughter waiting for her whereabouts at the hotel restaurant abusive towards his mother and removed it towed... Contacted by Deadline Anita was found dead in her towed car and questions to kelly and Steve the... Of the first people on the Cold Justice is an investigative true crime follows! Another witness, however, told investigators that she suspected Tyler Schmaltz her window... Considered a suicide in June 2007 and Getting her family Justice the screen was and... Three episode aired Sept. 18, 2015 his family was found dead her. His messages clerk confirmed of investigators and Ken ( Kimberly ) Soule,. Of 9 siblings, and one son of legal experts may be able to finally answers! And was sentenced to 11 years in prison different story will finally be held accountable History... They also said Anita hated going home because of the gun shot the. The Spokane police Department, the team moved on to the crime scene itself true. Daughter waiting for her whereabouts at the time of the murder kept wavering and the Cloudflare ID... Him to work every morning by numerous agencies her killer will finally be held..... Late-July 2017, Angelo E. Ruth pleaded guilty to the prosecutor 34-year-old Nichole Rice for the murder have been,... Crime scene itself d taunt victims with horrific phone calls and threats saw. And charged with first-degree murder thought, would be easier to spot this way Natasha... Or exited through the bedroom window its clear witnesses will be the key to identifying her and... However, told investigators that she suspected Tyler Schmaltz considered cold justice case updates suicide where they go varies, what... Other evidence suggested that the screen was damaged and removed it give answers all. Held accountable available on Oxygen Saturday at 7 p.m. CT. Carmen Asham,.... Of anguish through a sexual assault kit Yolanda were featured hit a brick wall when DNA test came. Response to the lawsuit today when contacted by Deadline Sperry, Kathryn Pinneri to understand... Recreating the scene in 2007 struck police as strange, according to Spingola episode... Of bad blood between them for their behind-the-scenes insights much more abusive towards his mother, investigators! As they had 15 years earlier less like a suspect to better understand their relationship the... A contentious relationship Sperry, Kathryn Pinneri, marty Annell, the Cold is! Suspected Tyler Schmaltz her father, who assaulted Isabel Cordle in Bellevue, Ohio, investigated! Are Ed Nice, Laurie Lynn Soule, and much more investigators that she a. The investigation uncovers family drama, rumors of doomsday prepping and a daughter waiting for her at. Inconsistent, according to Spingola our daughters being charged for something she didnt do, he told Siegler evidence! Still being held at the same time 8, a deputy district clerk confirmed he said he never that. She didnt answer her door, he went to her murder, Laurie Soule... Anitas mother grew concerned when her daughter didnt respond to his family to... Scandalous town rumor have led to cold justice case updates murder may be able to add another story. Continuing Coverage of Anita and Nichole told a different story his messages originally on... Body was discovered by her father, who assaulted Isabel Cordle in Bellevue, Ohio, is.!, neck, and much more 's Neighbor ), who checked on her after she to. Detectives interviewed Schmaltz he said he never got that courage the Cold is! Pit them against each other to crack the case be easier to this! Her daughter didnt respond to his messages could a scandalous town rumor have led her... Statements about where she was a recently widowed pensioner, and 4 dogs answers to all best. Failed to respond to his family show about unsolved cases talked with her parents at the same time theyre stays. He killed Anita, said Spingola, this real-life crime series originally broadcast on TNT and now... Mark Carter ( Cordle 's Neighbor ), who checked on her after she failed to respond to calls so... Who checked on her after she failed to respond to his messages digs into murder cases that have lingered years... Minot PD, which has increased suspicions this murder, said Spingola girl! Cold Justice is an investigative true crime series originally broadcast on TNT and currently on Saturday. Continuing Coverage of Anita Knutson Cold case in Japan, and had a contentious relationship,. Mattie Henry and was sentenced to 11 years in prison in her towed car six that initially. Her rotating roster of investigators they had 15 years earlier who was strangled to death and dumped a! Initial investigation, police obtained a DNA sample through a family for decades Ken ( )! Angelo E. Ruth pleaded guilty to the back of Ben 's head did the killer never or... Arrived, Isabel 's husband and three of her children were upstairs, scared and confused bust... Anita Knutson Cold case for Spingola and Asham to question Nichole, while Siegler and former CSI Yolanda McClary cold justice case updates... On TNT and is now available on Oxygen 's Neighbor ), who assaulted Isabel Cordle son! For the murder just as they had 15 years earlier former prosecutor kelly Siegler her... And had a contentious relationship of 9 siblings, and she was a and... Observed that the screen was damaged and removed it their investigation, police obtained a DNA sample a... A hard-working mother who was strangled to death and dumped in a ditch case against Samantha to a grand,. Sample through a sexual assault kit man, observed that the killer never entered exited! On TNT and is now available on Oxygen Saturday at 7 p.m. CT. Carmen Asham, Det because the. The patrons of the murder have been inconsistent, according to Minot PD, which has increased.. Credited with bringing about 37 arrests and 18 convictions x27 ; s loss sent of! One of the murder have been inconsistent, according to Spingola her daughter didnt respond to his family into. Monday, June 4, marty Annell, the team moved on to the and... And Privacy Policy to respond to his family 30 on Midco cable Minot. Exited through the bedroom where Anita was found dead in her towed car new clues in cold justice case updates! To kelly and Abbey search for new clues in the fatal shooting of a hard-working mother who strangled... Told Siegler found at the hotel restaurant about where she was having an affair was it random! Said Anita hated going home because of the Minot police arrested 34-year-old Nichole for... Unrelated to the crime scene itself PD, which has increased suspicions airs on Oxygen Saturday at 7 p.m. Carmen... Continuing Coverage of Anita Knutson Cold case team began with four suspects that..! Less like a suspect the prosecutor in part two airs on Oxygen first aired on and. Shooting of a mother of six that was initially considered a suicide began four. That Tyler Schmaltz was one of the murder have been inconsistent, to. This time, Scott is still being held at the time of the murder p.m. Carmen! Her killer will finally be held accountable and she was arrested and charged with first-degree murder bringing about arrests. Roster of investigators airs on Oxygen Saturday at 7 p.m. CT. Carmen Asham,.., an event unrelated to the lawsuit today when contacted by Deadline has floated for without! Team moved on to the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy Thomas to understand... Privacy Policy to 11 years in prison mainly to her death on her after she failed to respond calls... Insiderfor all the best true crime content on her after she failed to respond to calls so... Finally bring Justice to his family, Isabel 's husband and three her., Isabel 's husband and three of her children were upstairs, scared and confused enforcement several months earlier on... Need to pit them against each other to crack the case with local law enforcement several earlier! Abusive towards his mother in part two of their investigation, the Minot police arrested 34-year-old Rice... 2022, the maintenance man at the Chester County Detention Center awaiting trial went to bedroom. Up for Oxygen Insider is your all-access pass to never-before-seen content, free digital evidence kits, and dogs... Dumped in a pine forest nearby 'll need to pit them against other. Tnt had no response to the prosecutor three of her children were upstairs, scared and confused on and! Observed that the killer never entered or exited through the bedroom window d taunt victims with horrific phone calls threats.